Rey, Matthieu, When
Parliaments Ruled the Middle East, Iraq and Syria, 1946-63, Cairo New York:
The American University in Cairo Press, 2022
Matthieu Rey in When
Parliaments Ruled the Middle East, Iraq and Syria, 1946-63 doesn’t provide
a completely convincing argument that parliamentary democracy became the basis
of post-World War II politics in Iraq and Syria. Rey’s thesis is that during
the end of the Ottoman period until the early 1960s a new elite emerged in Iraq
and Syria that wanted Western style political reforms and pushed
parliamentarianism as the way to achieve them. It expanded representation but
also led to divisions which eventually ended the system. Rey does prove that
parliamentarism persisted in both countries despite coups and would be
autocrats. On the other hand he downplays many issues like corrupt elections,
how assemblies lacked power and how there were never any substantive reforms.
That’s why his book doesn’t completely pass the test.